Amazon Wish List Alternative for Any Store (2026)

Short answer: Since Amazon retired its "Add to Amazon Wish List from any website" button in 2023, Amazon lists only hold Amazon products, and gift-givers need an Amazon account to buy. If your wishes come from Target, Etsy, Sephora, Lululemon or small shops, use a universal wishlist such as Giftbuster (free, any store, relatives reserve without an account) or GiftList.

Disclosure: written by Giftbuster. Amazon facts checked November 16, 2026.

Amazon Wish List vs a universal wishlist

Amazon Wish ListGiftbuster
StoresAmazon onlyAny online store
Givers need an accountTo buy, yes (Amazon)No, reserve from the shared link
Reservations hidden from you✓✓
Price alerts✓ for Amazon items✓ for items from any store
Shipping addressCan share your addressNever asks for your address
PriceFreeFree, no ads

In our holiday data, fewer than one in five items Giftbuster users saved came from Amazon. Most wishes come from other stores.

How to switch in 5 minutes

  1. Create a free list in Giftbuster on your phone or at giftbuster.app.
  2. Add items from any store: on a phone, tap Share → Giftbuster on a product page, or paste a product link into Add item. Amazon links work too.
  3. Tap Share and send one link to family by text or email.
  4. Relatives open it in any browser and tap Reserve. You won't see what they picked.

Make your free list

FAQ

Can I add non-Amazon items to an Amazon Wish List? Not anymore. Amazon discontinued its add-from-any-website button and the Amazon Assistant extension in 2023.

What is the best alternative to Amazon Wish List? A universal wishlist app such as Giftbuster or GiftList. Giftbuster is free, works with any store and lets relatives reserve without an account.

Can I still include Amazon items? Yes. Paste the Amazon product link and Giftbuster fills in the name, photo and price.

Will my family see my address? Giftbuster never asks for a home or shipping address. You decide whether to share it.